Healthy food - healthy heart?

A lot is written about the right diet for heart patients, some of which has turned out to be myths. Read here why these 3 nutritional myths belong in the realm of fairy tales.

True or false:

People affected by chronic heart disease in particular should often consume omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids. These have a protective effect on the blood vessels.

This is only partly true. In principle, polyunsaturated omega fatty acids are quite healthy. However, they differ in their effect on the body: omega-3 fatty acids are effective against inflammation, blood clots and cardiac arrhythmia, and they also lower blood pressure. The composition of fats in the blood and the health of the blood vessel walls can also be improved by a diet rich in omega-3 fatty acids.

Omega-6 fatty acids, on the other hand, can both help against and promote inflammation. This is because the body can produce pro-inflammatory molecules from this fatty acid. Therefore, the ratio of omega-6 fatty acids to omega-3 fatty acids in the diet should not exceed 5:1. Fatty sea fish such as mackerel, salmon or herring contain the right ratio of fatty acids. Meat consumption, on the other hand, should be reduced as it mainly contains omega-6 fatty acids.

True or false:

"Heart failure often occurs with overweight and obesity. If people are already affected by heart failure, being overweight is always unfavorable for the further development of the disease."

This is also only partially true. In principle, it is true that overweight and obesity are associated with a number of diseases, meaning that they occur much more frequently in these people. These include heart failure (cardiac insufficiency), diabetes mellitus (diabetes), high blood pressure (hypertension) and coronary heart disease. Most of these diseases also improve if those affected lose weight and exercise regularly. Surprisingly, however, people who already have the disease have a higher chance of survival if they have a body mass index (BMI) of 25-35.

The body mass index (BMI)

The BMI is a measure of body weight in relation to height. You can calculate your BMI yourself here. Between a BMI of 19 and 25, we speak of normal weight, overweight begins above this, and at a BMI of 30 and above, we speak of obesity.

Understanding the Obesity Paradox
You might have heard that being overweight or obese increases the risk of many health problems, like heart disease or diabetes. That’s true. But here’s something surprising: some studies have found that people who are overweight or mildly obese may actually live longer or recover better from certain serious illnesses than people who are thinner. This is called the “obesity paradox.”

Why might this happen?
Doctors and scientists are still trying to fully understand it, but here are a few possible reasons:

  • Fat tissue isn’t just storage – It produces helpful substances, like hormones that make you feel full and chemicals that reduce inflammation, which might protect the body during illness.
  • Extra energy reserves – People with more body fat may have more energy stored up, which can help them cope better during long illnesses or hospital stays.
  • Cholesterol and proteins – Higher cholesterol levels in overweight people might mean more protective proteins in the blood that help fight off harmful substances.
  • Weight loss from illness – People who are thinner might already be losing weight because of a serious illness, which can make their condition worse.

But there’s a catch
This doesn’t mean being overweight is healthy. People with a normal weight are less likely to get diseases like diabetes, high blood pressure, or heart disease in the first place. The obesity paradox only seems to apply after someone is already sick.

Also, some experts believe the paradox might be due to how studies are done. For example:

  • Some people lose weight because they’re already sick, not the other way around.
  • Body Mass Index (BMI), which is often used to define obesity, doesn’t always reflect how much fat or muscle someone has.

What does this mean for you?
The key takeaway is that maintaining a healthy lifestyle—with regular physical activity, balanced eating, and not smoking—is important for everyone, no matter your weight. If you’re living with a chronic illness, your doctor will consider many factors, not just your weight, when planning your care.

SYMPTOM CHECK

How are you doing? Find out now!

MORE

DOWNLOADS

You can download further materials here.

MORE

True or false:

As people with chronic heart disease should avoid animal fats, margarine is healthier for them than butter.

Margarine is often advertised as healthier because it is "purely plant-based" or can even actively lower cholesterol levels. The latter is particularly true for some products. They contain so-called phytosterols; these plant substances reduce the absorption of cholesterol in the intestine and can thus demonstrably lower cholesterol levels, especially LDL cholesterol. The cholesterol level in the blood is made up of LDL (low-density lipoprotein) and HDL (high-density lipoprotein). Many studies suggest that a low LDL cholesterol level could be good for preventing cardiovascular disease.

However, it has not been proven that products containing phytosterols reduce the risk of cardiovascular disease. The human body produces around 90% of the cholesterol that can be measured in the blood itself - intake from food is therefore by no means the only source of cholesterol. In addition, too many phytosterols are harmful: they can also damage the blood vessel walls and even increase the risk of cardiovascular disease in the event of an overdose. They not only reduce cholesterol absorption, but can also lead to an undersupply of β-carotene, which is also fat-soluble. Although you would have to eat quite a lot of margarine to reach these harmful levels, if you also eat cholesterol-lowering dairy products, sausage and bread, large amounts of phytosterols can quickly accumulate.

It is also true that vegetable fats are preferable to animal fats. However, this applies in particular to natural, unhydrogenated oils. As a rule of thumb, it is therefore better to put a little butter on your bread than a lot of margarine. If possible, use native, cold-pressed oils for fats.

Practical tip: freeze a thin layer of olive oil and use it as a spread! It is purely plant-based and contains lots of healthy antioxidants

  • References
    • Curtis JP et al (2005) The obesity paradox: body mass index and outcomes in patients with heart failure. Arch Intern Med 165:55-61.
    • Kenchiah S et al. (2007) Baody mass index and prognosis in patients with chronic heart failure: insights form the Candesartan in Heart failure: Assessment of Reduction in Mortality and morbidity (CHARM) program. Circulation 116 (6): 627-636.
    • I. Kiefer, Ch. Haberzettl, Ch. Panuschka, A. Rieder. Phytosterols and their importance in prevention. Journal of Cardiology 2002; 9(3): 96-101
    • Koch S. Omega-3 fatty acids up to date. Consequences and perspectives for nutritional counseling. Association of Dietitians. Ernährungs Umschau 2007; 8: 482-485.
    • www.nhs.uk/health-assessment-tools/calculate-your-body-mass-index/calculate-bmi-for-adults


    9-UK-5-16520-01 08-2025

Further topics

SWOLLEN ANKLES, FEET AND LEGS?
THAT COULD BE THE REASON.

HEART FAILURE AND WORK: HOW REINTEGRATION WORKS

DIAGNOSIS OF HEART FAILURE:
WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW NOW